The MySpace Generation: Marketing to Generation Y
That’s the title of my speaking topic for tomorrow. I’m up right after lunch. I expect to have board members and senior management in my session. And I’ve been losing sleep over this? Why?
Not because I’m 47 – technically on the cusp between the Baby Boomer Generation and Generation X. Not because I’m not prepared, in fact I think I may have over-prepared. I guess it’s because I feel like I’m going to poop in every marketer’s punch bowl tomorrow, and well, you’re my peeps.
But it’s been bugging me for some time now, so I have to say it. We have to STOP doing what doesn’t work. We need Marketing 2.0! Modern marketing. New tools in our toolbox. In doing my research I created a marketing/media timeline:

1681 is the year of the very first direct mail piece in America. A pamphlet published by William Penn.
“No Junk Mail” is a movement in Australia today.
1704 came the first newspaper in America. So far this year 3 major newspapers have gone out of print/business.
1876 was the first telephone call ever made. In 2003 Bush signed the Do Not Call Implementation Act to protect consumers from telemarketers.
1924 the first radio broadcast in America. In 1998 the Digital Millennium Copyright Act was passed allowing for Pandora type streaming commercial free customized radio.
1941 is the year of the first television broadcast in the US. Just 50 years later TiVo is invented changing the way we watch TV (commercial free).
1990 The world wide web is created. Marketers quickly tried to adapt this new medium to old school methods. Pop-up ads appeared and almost immediately software was created to block them.
How do you market to generation Y? You can’t. Period. So stop trying. Stop doing what doesn’t work. It’s no wonder the average age of a credit union member is 48 nationally. That’s one year older than me! Look at your web page, your last direct mail piece, listen to that radio ad you just produced, or clip out that newspaper ad and hang it on the wall above a teller’s desk- do you think anyone under 45 is really going to care?
It’s funny, but Generation Y acts very much the same way as our credit union founders. They are faced with exactly the same economic challenges, have traditional values and do not trust big banks but rather each other. They love to gather (think common bond) and give each other advice (think people helping people) they just don’t do it in the company lunch room. They do it on their phones and laptops on the subway, in the coffee shop, or just walking down the street.
We need to join this conversation. We need to stop TELLING them what they want and what they should do and start LISTENING to what they want and figure out what YOU should do.
Social network users are 3X more likely to trust peer opinions over advertising in purchase decisions.
1 word-of-mouth conversation = the impact of 200 TV ads!
We need to understand, word-of-mouth always has been, and always will be the best, cheapest and most effective marketing. Your direct mail pieces aren’t getting you word of mouth. They may get you some hot money.
Stop “going after” people and products and start targeting a problem. Kudos to Technology Credit Union for writing their own iPhone application! And to the 200 plus credit unions that are now Twittering (thank you Roger Conant for CUTweetTrack).
I don’t have all the answers. I don’t want to encourage R & D (rip off and duplicate) by just showing the things that credit unions are doing to attract this generation.
What are you doing in the Gen Y space that is worthy of a mention? What’s left of your common bond? Is there a cause in there you could get behind?
And because I’m going to be speaking to the League of IBM Credit Unions (now called the Alliance of Credit Unions) I leave you with their mantra. Think.

8 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 27, 2009 at 10:01 am
Roger Conant
Love the bird on the chart, Denise
May 27, 2009 at 11:34 am
Glenn Coble
Great blog, Denise… As you know I love the NPS but it is difficult to get some old fuddy-duddies in this business to understand. Recently I have had a surfeit of vendors contacting me to sell me a survey package. When I ask them why I need them when I have Survey Monkey and my NPS question they quickly tell me “Oh, we use the NPS in our survey.” Maybe someone can explain that to me.
In regard to the GenYers it seems to me that they have acute BS radar so I try to avoid sending, telling, broadcasting, or showing them crap. I am working to convince everyone in my credit union to wear a white hat with pride. If you can’t say (or do) something honestly don’t say (or do) anything at all.
I have also tried to do away with all those happy faces of every race, creed and color smiling off the front of my brochures (I’d really like to get rid of my brochures). Those idiots look brain dead.
Today I turn 63, you young puppy, and it has taken me this long to figure out that we marketers are not the captain of the ship (though I believe many of us would be pretty good at it), we are the harbor pilot who knows his surrounding environment and leads his ship in the dangerous waters close to home and brings her into dock safely.
May 27, 2009 at 12:23 pm
Kim
“Social network users are 3X more likely to trust peer opinions over advertising in purchase decisions.
1 word-of-mouth conversation = the impact of 200 TV ads!”
Can you cite your source? I’d love to use this in a social media proposal!
May 27, 2009 at 1:17 pm
Jonathan
Great post, except there was one thing you wrote that shocked me…I would have put you at 42, not 47 (points?). I love your phrase “poop in a punchbowl” despite the imagery it stirs up. The poor dead horse named Gen Y has been beat and beat and beat…but some still want a miracle cure. Turns out Gen Y wants….(drumroll please) a free checking account just like baby boomers, and convenience, no fees, and great services just like any other generation. Just because we like to sag our pants and listen to rap doesn’t mean we want credit unions and banks to sag their pants and start rapping too. I wish I could hear your presentation tomorrow…I am sure you will nail it. And thanks for always speaking the truth no matter how popular or unpopular it may be.
May 28, 2009 at 1:52 am
Denise Wymore
@Glenn – you are the reason I blog. And you so helped me make my point. Markets are “conversations” today – like the one we’re having. How much more fun, and enlightening is this?
Quick answer to NPS question: When survey companies say “Oh, we have the NPS question on there” it’s like a steak house saying “Oh, we have Jenny Craig meals on the menu – as SIDE DISHES!” Totally defeats the purpose of the DISCIPLINE of NPS. Less is more.
Happy Birthday my friend!
@Kim – I got those stats from a presentation posted on Slideshare by Marketing Savant. Quote number one was from Jupiter Research and quote number two from Buzz Agent.
@Jonathan – you have 5 brownie points on top of all the others you’ve received for always making my day. You’re right – I think a lot of people just want some silver bullet for marketing to this generation. When has marketing been easy? Seriously? Sure – we get to play with photos and fonts all day long (oh, and Glenn – thank you thank you for banning shiny happy people!!!) but we don’t want people to think we don’t have challenges!
Relationships are hard and they take time to build. That’s our real business.
May 28, 2009 at 8:17 am
Jim Jerving
Denise, good post. CU marketers have to rethink their strategies as our membership numbers are declining in many of our credit unions. Young folks just don’t see the value of joining because we haven’t figured out how to tell a compelling story. Listening is hard work… telling is easy.
May 28, 2009 at 10:21 am
Todd Dickerson
Great post, Denise. As a visual person, I also really like the timeline.
The old tools are becoming less and less effective – my hope is some of them will get smarter (newspapers have lots of demographic data – use it!) Let’s stop the madness, indeed!
June 25, 2009 at 8:57 am
A French Canadian Twitter Moment…. « Cult-ivation
[...] Christopher Stevenson let me speak on anything I wanted. I decided to bring out the controversial Marketing to Gen Y piece I debuted last month. This session creates quite a stir and I love [...]