NOTE: For purposes of this virtual funeral, Marketing will be defined as anything that is one way. Meaning, the member can’t be heard in the process. It is intended for them to pay attention – or go away and read this. Examples: television ads, radio ads, newspaper ads, direct mail and brochures.
I’ve been speaking a lot lately – about marketing – or the slow death of it – and I get mixed reactions. Some deer-in-the-headlights, some nodding in agreement, some defiant in disagreement. All valid.
If your credit union’s goal is to attract and retain younger members, these traditional marketing efforts will not work.
But let’s celebrate what was a great run. Pay our respects, share our stories and memories and celebrate the life that is ahead. All of these marketing mediums made us better people. We should be thankful for their place in history. They will be missed.
R.I.P. the Television Ad.
Show of hands: how many of you remember when television went off the air? I do.
It’s one of the main reasons I got a real job in high school rather than the not-so-lucrative-baby-sitting-gigs my mom was able to pimp out. We lived in a very Catholic neighborhood. Giant families. She would “offer” me up on a Friday night at like a dollar an hour to watch 6 brats scream their way through my evening. The best part about baby sitting – was when you weren’t. When those rug rats were all safely tucked into bed and you had the television all to yourself. And hopefully some Hostess product.
Then it happened, the clock outran the viewing time. You were left with nothing to watch but this:
And you did.
Counting the minutes until the parents would finally arrive, give you 5 dollars and drunk drive you home. Good times.
Television was captivating in the 70’s. There was no internet. No video games. No Wii. If you weren’t watching television I suppose you could listen to the radio, read a book or go explore nature. But why? When you could plop down in front of the boob tube!
There were only 4 stations back then and you had to get up to change the channel. If the reception was poor, you had aluminum foil and your fist to remedy that. Very high tech. Because there was so little to choose from, you could clip the TV Click out of the Sunday paper and post it on the fridge to see the entire week’s offerings and plan accordingly. If you missed a show, you missed it. No taping. No Hulu.com. Your only connection would be to hear, from co-workers, that JR Ewing was shot! Dang!
Commercials were put in place so we could run to the bathroom to pee or grab a soda. Most of your members today probably still watch TV the new-fashioned way. By endlessly clicking through their 180 channels, wading through commercials looking for something interesting to watch. There’s definitely hope that they might see our ad.
And we can tell the board that we are “out there” on television.
NEXT: The wake. What will television look like without ads?
10 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 19, 2009 at 1:43 pm
rebecca secor
I’d like to pay my respects, as well.
TV commercials were great. In fact, my mother tells me that, as a young child, I would sit and attentively watch as the commercials played on our television…but go back to my regular business during the actual show.
So, yes, one of my first loves was the television commercial.
Now, I do everything possible to avoid them…DVR, channel flip, mute…
I think we’re already experiencing what the world looks like without television ads – with what I call…ridiculously inappropriate product placement.
Do you remember the scene in Wayne’s World where Benjamin is talking to Wayne & Garth about having to give their sponsor, Noah’s Arcade, a spot on the show…and Wayne starts talking about not selling out?
Then they go into a series of very badly done product spots…my fav:
Benjamin: Look, you can stay here in the big leagues and play by the rules, or you can go back to the farm club in Aurora. It’s your choice.
Wayne Campbell: [holding a can of Pepsi] Yes, and it’s the choice of a new generation.
November 19, 2009 at 2:43 pm
Denise Wymore
Rebecca,
So true! And remember all the blatant product promotion on Seinfeld? Pez. Snapple. Junior Mints – dropped in the body of a patient on the operating table…..good stuff……but alas, all good things must come to an end.
November 19, 2009 at 8:35 pm
Ryan Kendrick
You’re definitely right, Denise. But I’m afraid we’re just trading one annoyance (2-minute commercial segments) for something even worse: blatant product placement throughout a show, or (even worse) those distracting crawlers across the screen that have people walking around, smiling and waving at you to draw your attention to them (am I making sense?). You can’t skip those with your Tivo remote.
I know this isn’t a post about TV commercials as much as it is about the transformation (“death”) of traditional marketing. The only question is this: Is the new, evolving type of marketing companies are going to have to engage in worse or better than the existing types? If not done right, this new marketing is going to alienate a lot more people than current marketing options.
November 20, 2009 at 6:05 am
Denise Wymore
Ryan,
You pose an interesting question: “Is the new, evolving type of marketing companies are going to HAVE to engage in worse or better than the existing types?”
I believe that the kind of marketing COMPANIES are going to HAVE to engage in is Word-of-Mouth. Here’s the rub.
Media buyers and Chief Marketing Officers still believe that if the spot is clever enough and carefully placed (like some annoying dude running across the bottom of the screen during my episode of The Office) that it will boost sales.
Ad sponsored television is going to go the way of the Music Store. As in gone. I truly believe this and will explain it in my next post….stay tuned and thanks again for your comments.
November 20, 2009 at 11:56 am
Glenn Coble
Marion, Ohio isn’t quite up to the times. Radio and television seem to work here but like the local newspaper they are worth far less. I use them for name recognition so that when we do all of our community outreach things people will recognize us. I have paid as little a $3 per tv spot, $200 for a full page color ad, and $1.50 for a 30 second radio spot.
A short note of interest: The night JR was shot, I was at a huge media gathering to promote the pre-season NIT in New York… Free food, Free presents and FREE booze. There were at least 400 in attendance. At 8 p.m. (or what ever time Dallas came on the air) I looked around the room and all but about 25 people were gone. They all had gone to their rooms to find out who shot JR. Only those of us who valued the booze more than life itself were still there. After everyone found out who shot JR they all returned for the booze, food, etc. Back then network TV could really deliver.
November 20, 2009 at 4:52 pm
Jim Jerving
Back then network TV could really deliver… today’s cable TV really delivers quality programs with writing and acting that is usually better than what comes out of Hollywood: Sopranos, Brotherhood, the Wire, Dexter, Madmen, to name only a few. Consumers will continue to vote for quality and pass on the rest.
November 27, 2009 at 2:22 pm
Susan Farnsworth
Media. Does the use of “mediums” drive anyone else crazy?
Glad I found you Denise. You’re giving me lots of homework to read, though.
November 27, 2009 at 2:31 pm
Susan Farnsworth
Okay, just finished reading your post on babysitting and the limitations of TV. Chuckled out loud, as I can relate. It was the night of the last episode of the Mary Tyler Moore Show. The one with Lou Grant, Ted the narcisistic weatherman, et al. My high school boyfriend had to work and was going to have to miss it. (The show was a classic, and the last episode almost had the draw of the last M.A.S.H. episode.) Solution: our buddy Ric AUDIO taped the show by setting up the TV next to the stereo, and we played the tape of the sound track in the car on the way to class the next day! Hulu, schmulu.
November 28, 2009 at 7:31 am
Denise Wymore
Susan,
I love that story. I did a similar thing when I fell in love with Clay O’Brien. Who is Clay O’Brien you ask? He was the little kid in The Cowboys with John Wayne. A short lived Tiger Beat Teen Idol.
Anyway – when they aired the movie on television for the first time I audio taped all the scenes with him in it (I think he was on screen like four times, and his character’s name was Hardy Fimps). Sitting in front of the TV for two hours holding onto a microphone with one hand and my two fingers poised of the “record” and “play” button with the other.
Here’s the link to his short lived acting career and impressive rodeo career – oh yes, my boy was a REAL cowboy! LOL!
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0639475/bio
December 1, 2009 at 7:37 am
Stan Cowan
Timing is everything… I just had this conversation with my CEO 2 weeks ago (traditional mktg is dead) and now look…your blog appears!
Read the TV and the Radio one…can’t wait for the next installment!
http://www.twitter.com/stancowan